83 032
Fashion Jobs
ADIDAS
Project Manager - Global Team Sports
Permanent · PORTLAND
QVC
Security Shift Leader
Permanent · SUFFOLK
QVC
on Camera Talent Recruitment & Casting Partner
Permanent · WEST CHESTER
BLOOMINGDALE'S
Asset Protection Visual Security Officer, Part Time - Norwalk
Permanent · NORWALK
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Full Time
Permanent · FRANKLIN
BELK
Asset Protection Lead - Full Time
Permanent · AUBURN
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Full Time
Permanent · SAVANNAH
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Part Time - Independence Mall
Permanent · WILMINGTON
BELK
Asset Protection Associate - Full Time
Permanent · ROCKY MOUNT
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Part Time - Coastal Grand
Permanent · MYRTLE BEACH
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Full Time - Bridgestreet
Permanent · HUNTSVILLE
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Full Time
Permanent · TUPELO
BELK
Store Fulfillment Associate - Part Time
Permanent · SAVANNAH
BELK
Asset Protection Manager - Triangle
Permanent · RALEIGH
ALO YOGA
Construction Project Manager
Permanent · LOS ANGELES
SUN VALLEY
Sun Valley Marketing Manager
Permanent · SUN VALLEY
LULULEMON
Community Specialist | (Contract) Market Street The Woodlands
Permanent · THE WOODLANDS
LULULEMON
Community Specialist | Orlando Premium Outlet
Permanent · ORLANDO
LULULEMON
Full-Time Community Specialist | Cumberland Mall
Permanent · ATLANTA
FOSSIL
Dam/Dynamic Media Administrator
Permanent ·
KOHLS
Operations Supervisor - Weekend Days
Permanent · PLAINFIELD
KOHLS
Technical Project Manager
Permanent · MENOMONEE FALLS
By
Reuters
Published
Jul 30, 2018
Reading time
2 minutes
Download
Download the article
Print
Text size

IBM wins $83 million from Groupon in internet patent fight

By
Reuters
Published
Jul 30, 2018

A U.S. jury on Friday awarded International Business Machines Corp $83 million (63.29 million pounds)in a patent dispute with e-commerce company Groupon Inc. 




A jury in Delaware said Groupon used IBM’s patented e-commerce technology without authorization following a two-week trial.

“IBM invests nearly $6 billion annually in research and development, producing innovations for society,” IBM spokesman Douglas Shelton said in a statement. “We rely on our patents to protect our innovations. We are pleased by the jury’s verdict.”

“We continue to believe that we do not infringe on any valid IBM patents,” Groupon spokesman Bill Roberts said in a statement. “To the extent these patents have any value at all — which we believe they do not — the value is far less than what the jury awarded.”


The jury said Groupon’s infringement was willful, allowing IBM to ask a judge to award additional damages.

IBM had sought $167 million in damages, saying it developed widely licensed technology crucial to the development of the internet. Two of the patents relate to Prodigy, IBM’s late-1980s precursor to the web.

Groupon argued that some of IBM’s patents should not have been granted because they describe obvious ideas, and said the computing company’s damages request was unreasonable.

Armonk, New York-based IBM has secured more U.S. patents than any other company for the past 25 years.

The case was closely watched in the technology industry because it offered a glimpse into IBM’s efforts to license its large patent portfolio to other companies.

An IBM licensing executive testified that Amazon Inc, Facebook Inc, Alphabet Inc’s Google, LinkedIn and Twitter Inc have each paid IBM $20 million to $50 million as part of cross-licensing deals that gave them access to the patent portfolio.

In 2017 IBM generated about $1.2 billion in revenue from its licensing activities.
During the trial Groupon lawyer J. David Hadden portrayed IBM as using outdated patents to squeeze money out of other tech companies with threats of litigation.

IBM lawyer John Desmarais told jurors the company had no choice but to sue after Groupon refused to take responsibility for using IBM’s foundational technology.
“The verdict is a vindication for IBM’s licensing program,” Desmarais said by phone.

© Thomson Reuters 2024 All rights reserved.

Tags :
Industry