×
36 731
Fashion Jobs
BANANA REPUBLIC
General Manager - Willowbend Mall
Permanent · Plano
TOO FACED
Account Executive - Manhattan, New York
Permanent ·
GIII APPAREL GROUP
Accounts Payable Coordinator
Permanent · New York
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
Outside Sales Representative - Professional Beauty
Permanent · Mesa
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
Dbe Barber Account Executive
Permanent · New York
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
Dbe Barber Account Executive
Permanent · Nashville
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
Outside Sales Representative - Professional Beauty
Permanent · Eugene
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
District Manager
Permanent · Winston-Salem
SALLY BEAUTY CORPORATE
Outside Sales Representative - Professional Beauty
Permanent · Reno
CENTRIC BRANDS
Associate, Account Executive - Los Angeles (Hudson)
Permanent · Los Angeles
CENTRIC BRANDS
Area Manager - Bcbg - Texas
Permanent · New York
CENTRIC BRANDS
Senior Analyst - m&a - Business Development
Permanent · New York
CENTRIC BRANDS
Sales Manager, Bcbg - Division - Fashion Valley 624
Permanent · San Diego
ULTA BEAUTY
Prestige Sales Manager-Alabaster Promenade
Permanent · Alabaster
ULTA BEAUTY
Prestige Sales Manager-Shoppes of Mentor
Permanent · Mentor
ULTA BEAUTY
Prestige Sales Manager-Marshall's Plaza
Permanent · DeWitt
ULTA BEAUTY
General Manager-Lincoln Square
Permanent · Arlington
ULTA BEAUTY
Prestige Sales Manager-Water Tower Place
Permanent · West Des Moines
ULTA BEAUTY
Prestige Sales Manager-Ocean County Mall
Permanent · Toms River
ULTA BEAUTY
Retail Sales Manager-Water Tower Place
Permanent · West Des Moines
ULTA BEAUTY
Retail Operations Manager-Ocean County Mall
Permanent · Toms River
ULTA BEAUTY
Retail Operations Manager-Firewheel Town Center
Permanent · Garland

Shoplifter extortion case against Walmart, other retailers is dismissed

By
Reuters
Published
today Feb 11, 2019
Reading time
access_time 2 minutes
Share
Download
Download the article
Print
Click here to print
Text size
aA+ aA-

A federal judge dismissed a racketeering lawsuit accusing Walmart Inc and six other retailers of extortion by forcing accused shoplifters to take costly “restorative justice” classes or else be reported to the police.


Reuters


In a decision late on Friday, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California, found no proof of a nationwide conspiracy to steer accused shoplifters into paying $400 up front or $500 in installments for the classes from Utah-based Corrective Education Co, and admitting guilt, to avoid prosecution.

Shoplifting is the main source of inventory “shrinkage” for U.S. retailers, causing losses of about $559 per incident, and together with so-called organized retail crime about $17.1 billion in 2017, according to the National Retail Federation.
Koh said the three plaintiffs, who were accused in 2017 of shoplifting from Walmarts in Florida, Georgia and Texas, did not show that the retailers had specific knowledge of a conspiracy.

She said it did not matter that the retailers might use Corrective Education’s database to conduct background checks before deciding to offer the six-to-eight-hour online classes, a portion of whose costs the plaintiffs said was reimbursed to retailers.

“The only alleged commonality each of the defendants have with one another is CEC, whom plaintiffs have chosen not to sue,” Koh wrote. “That is not enough to allege one single nationwide conspiracy.”

Koh also said she lacked jurisdiction over most defendants in the proposed class action because they did not have enough ties to California, and said the plaintiffs lacked standing to sue retailers that did not harm them.

She gave the plaintiffs 30 days to amend their claims against Walmart, Corrective Education’s founders and some of its employees and directors.

Claims against Bloomingdale’s, Burlington Coat Factory, Kroger Co, 99 Cents Only, Save Mart and Sportsman’s Warehouse were dismissed with prejudice, meaning they cannot be brought again.

The plaintiffs were identified as Jane Doe, Mary Moe and John Roe. Their lawyers did not immediately respond on Saturday to requests for comment. Walmart and its lawyers did not immediately respond to similar requests.

Scott Gant, a partner at Boies Schiller & Flexner representing the Corrective Education defendants, said he was pleased with Koh’s thoughtful opinion.
Walmart suspended its use of Corrective Education’s classes in December 2017, the Wall Street Journal said that month.

The case is Doe et al v Walmart Inc et al, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, No. 18-02125.

© Thomson Reuters 2019 All rights reserved.